Gentoo recently released . One includes KDE and the other includes GNOME. I tried out the KDE version.
I've always been impressed by Knoppix, a Live CD for PCs with hardware detection second to none. Unfortunatly the Gentoo live CDs offer little of that but Gentoo has always been famed for its hardcore hacker reputation. There's no network setup on booting, I had to run dhcpcd eth0 to start it manually. Hard disks arn't mounted automaticly and there is no hfs utils or hfsplus utils, but impressivly HFS+ partition mounting, reading and writing is supported by the kernel. The volume is set to zero initially but after adjusting with kmix the sound works perfectly without any of the usual endian problems.
X isn't setup either, you're dropped into a command line with instructions to run Xeasyconf, Gentoo's text menu based XF86Config file generator. It's autodetection didn't work but then neither does Yellow Dog Linux's. I was able to get X working by simply manually selecting fbdev. Running startx as instructed starts up twm, a surprise since KDE is the main feature on this CD. Use kdm to get KDE started.
It's all stock software, a standard KDE build but it's right up to date with KDE 3.1.2, Mozilla 1.3, X 4.3.0 and Linux 2.4.21. Apache 2 failed to work due to an error in the configuration file caused by missing modules. Other quibbles include the default fdisk is the dos version, use mac-fdisk and KLaptopDaemon complains that my iMac has run out of battery.
I'm impressed at the effort that must have gone into making this, a labour of love for a small audience. The lack of hardware detection means it is unlikely to convert many MacOS X users but it might intrigue them and with over a gigabyte of software compressed onto the disk there's plenty to play around with.
Copyleft (GNU FDL) Jonathan Riddell 2003